The International Dairy Foods Association has released a list of America’s most popular ice cream flavors. The IDFA polled ice cream makers and retailers as well as consumers to try and find out the most popular ice cream choice. However, the IDFA learned that the most popular choice depends on who you ask. Top 5 Flavors According To Ice Cream Makers And Retailers: 1. Cookies N’ Cream 2. Vanilla 3. Chocolate 4. Mint Chocolate Chip 5. Strawberry Top 5 Flavors According To Consumers: 1. Chocolate 2. Cookies N’ Cream 3. Vanilla 4. Strawberry 5. Chocolate Chip The IDFA also revealed that chocolate is the most popular topping sauce, with 26% of people choosing it as their favorite. Caramel was the second most popular choice of sauce, with 18% of respondents choosing it as their favorite.